That is great - looks like you are really getting somewhere

I'm not sure what shape/size a rubber door stop is!!
The S/S scrubbers I get from Tescos are a couple of inches across and look kind of doughnut shaped (without the hole). I just pull either side a bit to elongate it and then stuff it into the hole at the top.
Three scrubbers seems to be the optimum amount.
I'd suggest running it like this.
1. Fill urn with wash, clamp lid on.
2. Check water flow to ensure both pipes are working about 50/50.
3. Switch power on to max
4. When column temp hits 40 turn the water on (the col temp will drop back to about 30)
5. When the column temp hits 70 degrees drop the power controller to about 800 watts.
6. Twiddle thumbs for a bit
7. When the colum temp climbs back up to 70 degrees increase the water to the reflux jacket and let the temp drop a little.
8. Let the col temp should stabilise somewhere about 70 degrees. Let it stay under 70 degrees for about 20/30 mins. This is to ensure the foreshots come out first and to compress the heads as much as possible.
9. Carefully reduce the water flow to the reflux jacket just a little bit and let the column temp rise a little. This is the really really crucial stage where you want to take care and pay attention.
10. Repeat step nine until you get some output.
11. Throw away your foreshots.
12. This is where you decide how fast/slow you want to run. You can either reduce the power to slow the output (I ran as low as 500 watts one day but found it difficult to maintain) or increase the water to the reflux jacket. Both have the same effect. The slower the output the higher the abv but the longer you'll be running. It's a fine line. I used to aim for a drop every second which meant long run times but high purity.
13. Monitor the column temp - it will rise but as it does increase the water flow to the reflux jacket to counteract it. Small changes on the water are needed!
I'm not discussing about taking cuts etc (heads/hearts/tails) as they should be covered elsewhere - this is merely what worked for me running my SS reflux.
Provided you do roughly the same thing each time then you should get roughly the same output. If the wash in is roughly the same ABV then you should get roughly the same output each time. If the ABV of your wash changes from run to run then you need to adapt.
I hope this helps.