No probs Brian, you can disagree with me anytime you like cause I know it's not personal
I should have included in my post that I don't have the blue lid on mine as I disposed of it shortly after I got the filter because of that very point. I replaced mine with a Stainless Steel saucepan lid and assumed anyone reading the postings here about the Essencia would have done so too.
That prompted me to look up my original report on the Essencia from many years ago which, I'm sure, included that point but it must have been among the huge number of my posts deleted by that moron we had to get rid of for causing trouble hereabouts a few years back
At the time I had some trouble with the filter and emailed the company in NZ and next thing I got a phone call from a Brian Maguire of Essencia in NZ and in the course of that lengthy conversation a number of things were discussed and I think, over the years, I have amalgamated a number of those things into my own beliefs on the use of the system.
One of the things Mr Maguire assured me of was that the body parts of the main filter are made from a material that is completely safe for extended use with Ethanol but that they recommend that spirits should be diluted to 40% ABV before filtering for normal purposes and that in any event Ethanol over 55%ABV cannot be properly filtered by the Carbon cartridge. On this basis I have always held that the filter is safe to use - minus the blue lid as you said

Somewhere along the way I adopted 50%ABV as a general safe point.
On the reputable company thing, I have bought Essencia products for a number of years and any problems I run into were minor and they always respond promptly if I contact them. The fact that Mr Maguire telephoned me from NZ says a lot about their attitude to customer service in my book. Of course you're absolutely right about the blue lid and I've emailed them about this but I'm not holding my breath on a change. I know I'm not on their Christmas card list because I've posted quite a bit, including photos, on refilling the Carbon Cartridges and they do read this forum, as well as others, for any mention of their products.
Anyway, apologies if what I posted came across as misleading - that's not what I intended
AM
